At first, Liu Chaoyang could still rely on the new U23 policy of the FA to have some chances to play in Luneng. As Liu Chaoyang's performance in Luneng games got worse and worse, he became the team's chicken ribs. For this reason, Liu Chaoyang has been rented out by Luneng many times, becoming a high salary burden for the team. Looking back at Liu Chaoyang's career, he did have good stats when he was playing in the Chinese B and Chinese A. Once he got to the Chinese Super League, he had a very difficult time. Therefore, it was also the right choice for Manatee to loan Liu Chaoyang to Chinese B team Guangzhou Leopard. It's better for Liu Chaoyang to be a starter for Guangzhou Leopards than to stay in Manatee and sit on the bench.
With the official announcement of Liu Chaoyang joining the China B team, fans are embarrassed by the past situation of Luneng 99 youth training duo. Guo Tianyu, who started out with Liu Chaoyang, was above Liu Chaoyang in terms of talent and starting point. With his hard work, Guo Tianyu played for a period of time in the starting lineup at Luneng and performed like a goal scorer, becoming the team's local Golden Boot. However, Guo Tianyu's self-discipline was so poor that he eventually went astray. Guo Tianyu has not made any public appearances since he was taken away. Some media reports said that he will stay away from professional soccer. So one of Luneng's 99 youth training twins fell to the Central B in the year he played, and the other is facing retirement without a ball.
