
When he first joined Luneng, Liu Chaoyang was still able to fight for some playing time in the team with the favorable U23 policy of the FA. However, as his performance in the game deteriorated, he gradually became the team's "chicken ribs" role. For this reason, Liu Chaoyang has been loaned out by the team many times and has become a piece of "hot potato" for the team. Looking back on Liu Chaoyang's career, his performance in the Chinese B and Chinese A leagues was indeed noteworthy, but when it came to the Chinese Super League, his form encountered a serious challenge. Therefore, it was a wise move for Manatee to loan Liu Chaoyang to Guangzhou Leopards in the second division. In Guangzhou Leopards, Liu Chaoyang will be able to become a starter in the second division, which is definitely a better choice than wasting his time on the Manatee's bench.
With the announcement of Liu Chaoyang officially joining the B team, fans can not help but feel saddened by the past situation of Luneng 99 youth training stars. Guo Tianyu, who started out at the same time as Liu Chaoyang, was slightly better in terms of both talent and starting point. Guo Tianyu by virtue of their own efforts, in Luneng once occupied the starting position, goal scoring efficiency is very high, become the team's local "Golden Boot". However, due to a lack of self-discipline, Guo Tianyu eventually went astray. Since his departure, he has made few public appearances. Some media reported that Guo Tianyu may stay away from professional soccer. As a result, Luneng's two youth stars, one is struggling to survive in China B, while the other is facing the shadow of retirement without a ball to play.










